Last Tuesday night will probably go down as one of my best — but also worst, footballing memories. At the time of writing, Stranraer FC's response to the charge of fielding an ineligible player against Queen's Park hasn't yet been heard. Perhaps common sense will prevail, and the emergency loan signing of a goalkeeper will be seen as just that — even if it wasn't spelt out in so many words. But it seems like the writing is on the wall. A second trip to Ibrox in five years, £200,000, all gone. As a fan, I'm devastated, but I'm sure it doesn't come close to how the players, coaching staff and committee are feeling.
In the week since it all unfolded, I've have two main reflections from a pastoral perspective. The first is that in the running of a club like Stranraer, as in the life of a church, unpaid volunteers do an astronomical amount of work behind the scenes, week after week, year after year. There are many who will never thank them for it — and yet will be the first to criticise them when they make a mistake. Lessons will be learned, but never forget that there are human beings at the centre of all this. It's too easy to forget that, particularly in this internet age.
The second reflection is that last Tuesday's match could be an illustration of what will happen to many who hope to get to heaven. If, as you read this, Stranraer have been expelled from the Scottish Cup, it won't be through a lack of effort. Our part-time players put in a phenomenal shift for 120 minutes in torrential rain against full-time opponents two leagues higher up. By the end of the game, some of them could barely walk. They had put their bodies on the line for the club and dug out a remarkable victory. But ultimately it was all for nothing. The outcome was already decided. If the club are deemed to have breached the rules, then no amount of exertion by the players could have changed that. As soon as the match kicked off, our fate was sealed.
It made me think of the effort that many put in, in the hope of one day getting to heaven. They do charitable deeds and other good works. They become committed churchgoers. Perhaps they even receive "long service certificates" for their efforts. But without Jesus, it's all in vain. He himself said "no-one comes to the Father except through me". The Bible puts it starkly: "Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only Son of God". Without first having put our faith in Jesus, then all our effort will be in vain. We are "condemned already" — before a ball is even kicked.
One man who was alert to that danger was the Apostle Paul. Before he began his missionary journeys, he wanted to check that the gospel he had believed and been preaching matched that of the other Apostles — "in order to make sure I was not running or had not run in vain". 120 minutes played in vain pales into insignificance compared to a life lived in vain. What a tragedy that would be! To have known about the eligibility issue before kick-off last week and said nothing would have been cruel beyond belief. Far more so when it comes to the danger of a life lived in vain.
If, as I suspect, the SFA ruling has gone against us by the time you're reading these words, I have no doubt the club will recover. Saturday's 2-0 win away to league favourites East Kilbride was evidence that the spirit and togetherness of the team hasn't been shattered by this unfortunate turn of events. But if any of us are ruled ineligible at God's tribunal, there's no recovery.
On the Day of Judgement, many will point to the effort that they put in: "‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’" But Jesus will tell them that they were ineligible the whole time — "I never knew you; depart from me, you workers of lawlessness."
The last week has been desperately disappointing for all those connected with Stranraer FC. But positives may yet come from it. If Saturday's performance is anything to go by, it will galvanise the team for the rest of league campaign. And maybe, just maybe, it will become for some an illustration of what it would be to run the race of life in vain.
Published in the Stranraer & Wigtownshire Free Press, 29th January 2026
